mailing list archives
Re: How to Test HDD Encryption
From: Ansgar -59cobalt- Wiechers <bugtraq () planetcobalt net>
Date: Wed, 14 Nov 2007 17:13:56 +0100
On 2007-11-14 jfvanmeter () comcast net wrote:
I recently completed a pen test for a client and discoveried a new
directory traversal in a web enable application. The target for the
test was FDE enabled , once the target was booted and the OS mounted I
could exploit the directory traversal to read any file on the system.
After I informed my client of the problem, they asked me to do
additional testing, I found if I encrypted the file, and ran the
directory traversal, I could no longer read the file.
So until the ventor patched there software, a mitigating step to lower
the risk was to encrypted the files the client felt were the greatest
risk if someone was to run the exploit.
First, hosts that are world-accessible should not hold sensitive data
in the first place. Second, services running on a world-accessible hosts
should be running under their own user account. Third, a directory
traversal will expose only those files that are accessible by the user
running the exploited service.
If encrypting the files mitigated the problem, then the user running the
service apparently didn't need access to those files. Thus revoking read
access for that user would have mitigated the problem just as well
without the additional overhead of file-level encryption.
I believe you need both, FDE to protect the data at rest, and file
encryption to protect the data when it is active.
I still fail to see an advantage of file-level encryption.
"All vulnerabilities deserve a public fear period prior to patches
--Jason Coombs on Bugtraq
RE: How to Test HDD Encryption jfvanmeter (Nov 14)
Re: How to Test HDD Encryption jfvanmeter (Nov 14)
Re: How to Test HDD Encryption jfvanmeter (Nov 15)
Re: Re: How to Test HDD Encryption DMonrad (Nov 15)
Re: Re: How to Test HDD Encryption jfvanmeter (Nov 16)
Re: Re: Re: How to Test HDD Encryption dmonrad (Nov 19)
- Re: How to Test HDD Encryption, (continued)