Bugtraq: IE chain vulnerability

[Alex Loots <a.loots () itsec-ss nl>]

Hello list,
I have a question regarding the IE certificate chain vulnerability
reported in MS02-050. The patch that fixes this vulnerability results in
strange behavior of IE when a connection attempt is being made to a
website which uses a malicious certificate.

I have set up a demo that uses a malicious certificate (A) that is
generated on 19-08-2002 by means of a website certificate (B) published
by a default IE trusted third party (C). Certificate B is valid from
17-08-2002 until 16-11-2002. When I connect to the malicious website
with the current date set on my client system (20-01-2003 at the time of
this writing) the patched IE gives a warning about the validity date of
the certificate and does not give any warnings regarding the faulty
certificate chain. In my opinion IE should tell exactly why the
certificate is not correct including the faulty chain. Most end users
don't even bother the warning about the date and continue browsing. This
happens all the time with valid certificates to so they have seen it
before.

When I set the date of my client system to a date between 19-08-2002 and
16-11-2002 it is not possible to connect to the malicious website. The
default IE “DNS or …” error page is being displayed. The error displayed
is not informative enough but IE at least keeps me from entering the
malicious site.

So even with a patched version of IE it is still possible to almost
transparently exploit the chain vulnerability because of incorrect
warnings.

I have tested this on a W2KPro system with a patched IE 5.0.

Has anybody also noticed this behavior?

I have contacted Microsoft two weeks ago about this issue but they have
not replied yet.

- Alex