mailing list archives
Strengthen OpenSSH security?
From: Brett Glass <brett () lariat org>
Date: Mon, 17 Apr 2006 22:31:52 -0600
I'm sure that most folks with hosts that expose an OpenSSH daemon
to the Internet have been getting the usual probes and password
guessing attempts and have been taking appropriate actions (e.g.
setting AllowUsers and using strong passwords) to protect
yourselves. But today, on one of my servers, I noticed a new trend:
the attackers are getting smarter. Apparently, they can tell the
difference between a user ID which is not named in an AllowUsers
directive -- or which does not exist at all -- from one for which
they just haven't guessed the correct password. I've now watched as
some attackers (but not all... yet) tried various user IDs, noted
which ones existed and were in AllowUsers, and focused password
guessing attacks on just those user IDs.
It seems to me that sshd should not tip its hand by returning
different responses when a user ID can be used for logins than when
it can't -- allowing an attacker to focus password guessing attacks
on user IDs with which it would have a chance of gaining access.
For those folks out there who are more familiar with OpenSSH than I
am: How hard would it be to make the responses indistinguishable?
- Strengthen OpenSSH security? Brett Glass (Apr 20)