Bugtraq: Privilege Escalation Vulnerability in Microsoft Windows

[advisory () htbridge com]

Advisory ID: HTB23108
Product: Microsoft Windows
Vendor: Microsoft Corporation
Vulnerable Version(s): Windows Vista, Windows Server 2008, Windows 7, Windows 8 RP
Tested Version: Windows Vista Ultimate SP1, Windows 2008 SP2, Windows 7 Professional SP1, Windows 8 RP
Vendor Notification: August 7, 2012 
Public Disclosure: October 9, 2012 
Vulnerability Type: Uncontrolled Search Path Element [CWE-427]
CVSSv2 Base Score: 6 (AV:L/AC:H/Au:S/C:C/I:C/A:C)
Risk Level: Medium 
Discovered and Provided: High-Tech Bridge Security Research Lab ( https://www.htbridge.com/advisory/ ) 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Advisory Details:

High-Tech Bridge Security Research Lab has discovered a vulnerability in Microsoft Windows which could be exploited to 
escalate privileges under certain conditions.

The vulnerability exists due to the “IKE and AuthIP IPsec Keying Modules” system service, which tries to load the 
“wlbsctrl.dll” DLL that is missing after default Windows installation.
The “IKE and AuthIP IPsec Keying Modules” service starts automatically in default configuration (after default 
installation) of:

 - Microsoft Windows Vista
 - Microsoft Windows 2008 
 - Microsoft Windows 7
 - Microsoft Windows 8 Release Preview

Moreover the service runs with SYSTEM privileges by default. Therefore an unprivileged local user who has write access 
to a default or any other search PATH locations can execute arbitrary code on the vulnerable system with the privileges 
of the SYSTEM account.


Vulnerability Details

The “IKE and AuthIP IPsec Keying Modules” service tries to loads the “wlbsctrl.dll” library which is missing. This 
forces Microsoft Windows to use search PATH procedure  to locate the missing dynamic-link file in the following order 
described by Microsoft - http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/desktop/ff919712%28v=vs.85%29.aspx
 - The directory from which the application loaded
 - The system directory
 - The 16-bit system directory
 - The Windows directory
 - The current directory
 - The directories that are listed in the PATH environment variable

When directory is created in the C:\ root folder, access permissions for files and subfolders are inherited from the 
parent directory. By default members of the Authenticated Users group have FILE_APPEND_DATA and FILE_WRITE_DATA 
privileges to all directories created within the C:\ root folder. This also applies to folders created by application's 
installer. The vulnerability is introduced to the system when software does not change default permissions to 
installation directory and adds its installation path to the PATH system environment variable. Any member of the 
Authenticated users group can place malicious file named “wlbsctrl.dll” into that folder and execute arbitrary code on 
the system after simple reboot.

A brief research confirmed that the following well-known software makes the weakness exploitable when installed into 
the C:\ root folder:

 - ActivePerl 5.16.1.1601 (default installation)
Adds to the PATH variable: C:\Perl\Site\bin;

 - ActiveTcl 8.5.12 (default installation)
Adds to the PATH variable: C:\TD\bin

 - ActivePython 3.2.2.3 (option to modify the PATH variable is inactive, but can be manually activated)
Adds to the PATH variable: C:\Python27\;C:\Python27\Scripts;

 - Ruby installer 1.9.3-p194 (option to modify the PATH variable is inactive, but can be manually activated)
Adds to the PATH variable: C:\Ruby193\bin;

 - PHP 5.3.17 (option to modify the PATH variable is inactive, but can be manually activated; must be explicitly 
configured to be installed into C root folder, e.g. C:\PHP)
Adds to the PATH variable: C:\PHP\;

 - Zend Server 5.6.0 SP4 (must be explicitly configured to be installed into C root folder, e.g. C:\Zend)
Adds to the PATH variable: C:\Zend\ZendServer\share\ZendFramework\bin

 - MySQL 5.5.28 (option to modify the PATH variable is inactive, but can be manually activated; must be explicitly 
configured to be installed into C root folder, e.g. C:\MySQL)
Adds to the PATH variable: C:\MySQL\MySQL Server 5.5\bin


Attack vectors

Any member of the Authenticated Users group can escalate his privileges to SYSTEM when the following conditions are met:
1. The above-mentioned software sets insecure privileges for installation folder (that is writable by members of the 
Authenticated Users group).
2. The above-mentioned software adds its installation path to the system PATH environment variable.


Proof of Concept

You can download the PoC (Proof of Concept) that demonstrates vulnerability exploitation under non-privileged user 
account on default installation of Windows 7 with default installation of the latest version of ActivePerl: 
https://www.htbridge.com/advisory/HTB23108-P0c-Windows-Services.rar

How to exploit:
1. Log in under an unprivileged system account.
2. Download and extract the HTB23108-P0c-Windows-Services.rar archive.
3. Copy the files from the archive into the C:\Perl\site\bin folder.
4. Reboot the system.
5. Log in under unprivileged system account.
6. Run the C:\Perl\site\bin\ADMC.exe file.
7. Enter the following credentials when asked:
Login: fox
Password: 1234
8. Type “shell” and then “whoami” command in the system console and you will see: “nt authority\system” – you have 
administrative console.


Conclusion

Many Windows services have missing DLLs, and search PATH procedure is a built-in Windows feature. However, in this case 
the service with the missing DLL runs by default with SYSTEM privileges. Combined with some well-known software in 
default installation this “feature” becomes a perfectly exploitable vulnerability under relatively spread Windows 
configuration.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Solution:

Official MSRC answer: 
Microsoft has thoroughly investigated the claim and found that this is not a product vulnerability. In the scenario in 
question, the default security configuration of the system has been weakened by a third-party application. Customers 
who are concerned with this situation can remove the directory in question from PATH or restrict access to the 
third-party’s application directory to better protect themselves against these scenarios.

Microsoft requested and validated to disclose the advisory on the 9th of October 2012.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

References:

[1] High-Tech Bridge Advisory HTB23108 - https://www.htbridge.com/advisory/HTB23108 - Privilege Escalation 
Vulnerability in Microsoft Windows
[2] Microsoft Windows - http://www.microsoft.com - Microsoft Windows is a series of graphical interface operating 
systems developed, marketed, and sold by Microsoft.
[3] Common Weakness Enumeration (CWE) - http://cwe.mitre.org - targeted to developers and security practitioners, CWE 
is a formal list of software weakness types. 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Disclaimer: The information provided in this Advisory is provided "as is" and without any warranty of any kind. Details 
of this Advisory may be updated in order to provide as accurate information as possible. The latest version of the 
Advisory is available on web page [1] in the References.