mailing list archives
Re: Re: Security Bug in MSVC
From: Jason Coombs <jasonc () science org>
Date: Thu, 19 Jan 2006 09:38:52 +1300
Dave Korn wrote:
Nice thinking, Donnie. This must be the "new class of vulnerability"
that was hinted at by Microserfs a few months ago... The attacks are
launched by way of source code distributions rather than binary code.
Why is this a terrible insecure microsoftism, when GNU make does exactly
Just after Donnie reported this issue to Microsoft (September) we
started seeing Microserfs suggest that their security team was working
on a never-before-encountered novel class of vulnerability, and the
implication was that Microsoft's security competency had finally
surpassed both the black hats and all other white hat groups -- since it
would be politically valuable for Microsoft to be able to claim that
sharing source code is an unsafe behavior, and since there have been no
other vulnerabilities disclosed since that time which might have
appeared to Microsoft to be entirely new and far-reaching, I suspect
that this disclosure prompted those previous statements about work being
done by Microsoft.
How many other attacks can you point to where Microsoft's development
tools are exploited to specifically target the unwary programmer who
still thinks it's perfectly safe to download arbitrary data from an
untrusted source and then open it in a text editor? My guess is that
Donnie got Microsoft thinking about this very risk, and they started
talking internally about it being an entirely new class of
vulnerability. Yes, if my supposition is correct it would be quite
pathetic and give us another reason to laugh at Microsoft; but you can
probably see how much benefit Microsoft is going to be able to milk out
of this and related attacks that exploit bugs in programmers' tools that
are launched by the simple act of opening or attempting to compile a
source code distribution.
Source code is just as dangerous as binary code. Clearly, the only way
to be safe is to rely on Microsoft's programmers to create and
digitally-sign software for us. Go Microsoft. Yeah!
Full-Disclosure - We believe in it.
Hosted and sponsored by Secunia - http://secunia.com/