mailing list archives
From: David Farber <farber () central cis upenn edu>
Date: Tue, 31 Jan 1995 08:48:25 -0500
CyberWire Dispatch // Copyright (c) 1995 //
Jacking in from the "Privacy: It's an Attitude" Port:
Washington, DC -- The IRS, we're now told, is creating a data base on
ordinary Americans that includes everything from news clips from your
home town paper to the information you scribble on a credit card
Oh... and don't mind if the information -- either in the cheesy
newspaper account or on the credit application is wrong: The IRS
doesn't care. They'll use it anyway. If you protest? Well, "fuck you"
is basically what the IRS demeanor.
In an attempt to thwart the ever increasing slide of personal privacy,
here are some quick & dirty lessons of an Information Subversive,
Janlori Goldman, currently with the newly founded Center for Democracy
and Technology, formerly with EFF and the ACLU where she ran privacy
I profiled Goldman for _Wired_ magazine; the quotes here are "out
takes" that didn't make it into that story.
On a really good day, Janlori Goldman becomes a vocal privacy advocate,
challenging any unsuspecting clerk that dares ask for her phone number
or social security number. "I lecture them and then refuse to give the
information," she said. Only once has the tactic backfired; the store
told her to walk.
But on bad days she becomes an "information subversive," by giving out
wrong or misleading information. "It's the lazy person's approach to
thwarting the system," she said.
She's not alone on her bad days. Hundreds of thousands throughout the
U.S. -- and spanning all age groups -- wage a similar kind of
low-intensity information warfare. "And this is one reason all these
databases are so unreliable," said Goldman. "They're filled with
But you don't have to sink to the info-subversive level, Goldman says,
there's also the thinking person's approach to privacy.
Here's how it works: When ordering or subscribing to something, use a
different middle initial or a slight misspelling of your last name. For
example, if you switch your middle initial to "X" when subscribing to,
say, _America Online_, and a month later you get some annoying direct
mail offering you a secluded beach front hideaway in Nicaragua, you'll
know whom _America Online_ is selling it's subscriber list.
Goldman said she doesn't have the energy to do this. "But it's
extremely clever because these people aren't subverting the system,
they're learning about the system," she said.
When people start to understand how their personal information is being
used -- or abused -- they can take charge. "I think when people start
to realize they have power [over control of their personal information]
they'll take a principled position," Goldman said. "There's nothing to
be lost in fighting for information control... If anything it's more
Meeks X. out...
- Info Subversives David Farber (Jan 31)