Home page logo
/

nanog logo nanog mailing list archives

Re: EMAIL != FTP
From: Sabri Berisha <sabri () bit nl>
Date: Fri, 25 May 2001 16:49:45 +0200 (CEST)


[cc: list removed]

On Fri, 25 May 2001, Mitch Halmu wrote:

If you were a dial-up user, chances are you wouldn't be able to do that.

If you were a dial-up user, FTP would be far more efficient. Ever thought
of the 8 to 7 bit conversion? The man page for uuencode says an expansion
of 37% is quite normal. I would prefer to wait 10 minutes instead of
almost 14 minutes for the same file.

Suppose a clueless user takes about 15 minutes to find out how it works;
if you use email regularly to transmit files, you will save time very
fast.

A few simple reasons come to mind: first, you wouldn't have any or not
enough disk space on your system account (limited by quota) to store the
file.

I think most ISP's prefer a onetime use of webspace instead of a 10 time
use in pop boxes.

Second, an average user probably wouldn't have the skill.

Then he/she should learn. I don't buy a car if I can't drive. I'm sorry
for comparing internetworking with driving a car but I feel that FTP'ing
is a basic skill if you want to use the internet in a professional way
(and since most documents are being distributed for professional reasons,
they should know).

Third, a .zip file will usually display as funny characters on a web
browser - that's why ftp is needed.

Most browsers can handle .zip files and ask the user what to do with them.

Fourth, you probably wouldn't have shell access and ftp space from
your provider with a regular account.

Then change ISP's.

Fifth, assuming you would have all the toys, you would have to spend
yourself the time to first upload the file, so that another may
retrieve it.

C:\windows\ftp.exe

ftp://www.bit.nl/~sabri/suexec.patch.gz

Sixth, if your file was a sensitive document, others
would have public access to it, etc.

http://foo:bar () www bit nl/~sabri/suexec.patch.gz

So what's a regular user to do? Email it! Hence the legitimate use of
email for transmission of large files. Most ISPs know that if they start
limiting this privilege, users will migrate to someone that allows it.

Allowing != promoting...

And like more people on this list; I consider it very rude to receive
large attachments, especially from clueless salesdroids sending .doc
files. That's the way to get me not buying anything.

imho of course.

-- 
/* Sabri Berisha CCNA,BOFH,+iO        O.O        Business Internet Trends
 * Join HAL!!: www.HAL2001.org ____oOo_U_oOo____ http://www.bit.nl/~sabri
 * ____________________________________________, +31 318648688  318643334
 * DDoS: http://misterpoll.com/3517731598.html L_______________________ */





  By Date           By Thread  

Current thread:
[ Nmap | Sec Tools | Mailing Lists | Site News | About/Contact | Advertising | Privacy ]
AlienVault