mailing list archives
Re: GPS SA and Network Timing
From: rs () seastrom com (Robert E. Seastrom)
Date: 26 Sep 2001 10:00:13 -0400
"Eric Germann" <ekgermann () cctec com> writes:
During the recent attacks, there was a brief discussion as to whether the
USG had or would invoke GPS SA. We have a client who is building a broad
ATM network and had planned to use GPS based timing solutions from TrueTime
for a clocking source, in addition to a feed from the LEC.
If GPS SA is invoked down the road during a crisis, what effect is there, if
any, on networks which rely on GPS for timing, not positioning?
If one is running in locked-position mode (supported by many receiver
elements that are designed specifically for timing applications such
as the Motorola Oncore UT; I'm not sure what is inside the Truetime,
but it wouldn't surprise me to find it's one of the Oncore family...),
induced error is substantially less, but even in the worst case,
you're looking at tens to a couple of hundred nanoseconds. In short,
nothing that you would notice if you're using GPS as an NTP source.
Be aware though (getting back to your original question) that even in
the best of times jitter on GPS is more than you would really like to
have for a telecom clocking application. This is mitigated somewhat
by the fact that you are not getting raw GPS data in most cases, but
rather the output from a crystal oscillator that is "steered" by GPS.
The high-end GPS-based units often have an OCXO instead of an
el-cheapo crystal, in order to help hold-over performance. The
GPS-based timing vendors would have you believe that GPS is every bit
as good as cesium for a stratum 1 frequency reference, and it's
probably good enough for you too, but if you want to be pedantic about
it, it's not as good. Does it really matter? I don't think so...
particularly in the context of the price of a Cs standard.
If the LEC is willing to give you a feed, though, why worry about it?
I've seen applications that only have a LEC feed run for years on end.
You could always get a rubidium standard (cheaper than Cs by a long
shot) if you're worried about what happens if your feed from the LEC