Home page logo

Nmap Announce mailing list archives

Re: firewalk meets nmap - TTL (advantages)
From: Darren Reed <avalon () coombs anu edu au>
Date: Sun, 5 Nov 2000 13:52:01 +1100 (Australia/NSW)

In some mail from Lance Spitzner, sie said:
Most firewalls only filter inbound traffic on the interfaces, not
outbound.  For example, when a firewall initiates a connection by
sending a packet, most firewall rulebases allow this connection because
the firewall is trusted. 

mmm, most but not all :)
Depends on the competancy of the firewall builder, I'd say :)

The same thing applies to the use of TTL settings during the scan.  You
set the TTL to the same number of hops to the firewall.  You then scan
the systems behind the firewall.  If the firewall does NOT filter the
packet and allows it to go through, it will first decremet the TTL and
then forward the packet.
However, since the TTL will now be zero, the firewall initiates an ICMP
Error message and sends it back to the source IP system (you).  This
packet is most likely allowed outbound since the firewall itself is
initiating the connection.

Or, because it is part of "error reporting", is recognised as being a part
of that connection.  I actually had this argument with someone recently -
are ICMP unreachables/time exceeds, etc, for a connection allowed through
just because they match ?  Yes, I'd argue, because they're part of the
"control channel" (for want of a better term).  So if you're letting in
SMTP connections to a mail relay and you do the stateful thing, the SYN
initiates the state and the retrun ICMP packet matches it (of course) so
is allowed.

If you're doing stateful filteirng, you can reduce this problem by just
letting the SYN packet in and triggering the state creation when it leaves
the box such that no time exceeds generated by the firewall are allowed
out "by default".  This doesn't negate the problem, however, as you can
(a) setup a "connection" to a known open service and then (b) use just ACK
packets with the right seq/ack #'s to do the right thing.

What you need to be able to do is (a) drop packets with a "too low" TTL
(1 or 2, basically) or (b) have a knob to disable allowing those packets
out or (c) be able to disable them matching state information.  All three
of these would be nice :)

But now if the firewall would accept icmp at least to outbound, this method 
should be reliable and should give us a good idea of what remote security 
rules look like but not in fact if really the target's port behind the 
firewall is open.

Most firewalls deny ICMP coming in from the Internet or ICMP coming from 
internal network.  Most firewalls do NOT block icmp initiated by the firewall 

I wish I could work out how to generate packets in IP Filter, on Solaris,
that bypass filtering!


For help using this (nmap-hackers) mailing list, send a blank email to 
nmap-hackers-help () insecure org . List run by ezmlm-idx (www.ezmlm.org).

  By Date           By Thread  

Current thread:
[ Nmap | Sec Tools | Mailing Lists | Site News | About/Contact | Advertising | Privacy ]