mailing list archives
Re: Physical access vulnerabilities and auto-mounting
From: Sebastian Krahmer <krahmer () suse de>
Date: Wed, 23 Feb 2011 08:33:48 +0100
Unfortunally I think nobody would care. As nobody cared
that you actually do not need physical access. Via udisks DBUS
service you can load any LKM via
dbus-send --system --print-reply --dest=org.freedesktop.UDisks \
I reported that several months ago to upstream but it was frozen to more
or less a non-issue. Indeed nobody agreed that this is an issue to fix.
On Tue, Feb 22, 2011 at 11:17:54PM -0500, Dan Rosenberg wrote:
I originally started writing this as a response to the recent CVE
requests for issues in partition handling, but thought it might be a
useful discussion on its own. I was wondering if there are any
clear-cut policies on issues involving physical access, since these
can be very difficult in terms of assigning blame.
For example, many Linux distributions will auto-mount filesystems on
removable storage, often going so far as to load corresponding kernel
modules for filesystems that aren't compiled in or don't already have
an LKM loaded. Sometimes, this will happen even if the screen is
Incidentally, many Linux filesystem implementations don't have
especially robust error handling for failures during attempts to mount
corrupt filesystems. As an example, I have a deliberately corrupted
btrfs filesystem that triggers a BUG() if you attempt to mount it. I
formatted a USB stick with this filesystem, so now I have a USB stick
that will panic the kernels of distributions that support
auto-mounting, in some cases even when the screen is locked.
Should this be considered a vulnerability? Probably. But what should
be fixed? Should auto-mounting be disabled entirely? Is it no longer
a vulnerability if auto-mounting is disabled only when the screen is
locked? Should all filesystems have graceful error handling for every
possible edge case that can occur when dealing with corruption?
I'd be interested to hear opinions on this. And depending on how the
discussion goes, I'd be happy to provide more details on specific
cases, such as the btrfs example.
~ perl self.pl
~ krahmer () suse de - SuSE Security Team
~ SUSE LINUX Products GmbH, GF: Markus Rex, HRB 16746 (AG Nuernberg)