Firewall Wizards mailing list archives

Re: Internet Security Review


From: Steve Kruse <jsk347 () worldnet att net>
Date: Mon, 13 Oct 1997 13:44:30 -0400

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

At 06:15 AM 10/13/97 +0000, Mark Teicher wrote:
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

What are people's thoughts on what an Internet Security Review is??  

What tools or programs would one use while conducting one, and how 
would one go about conducting one?


/mht



-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: PGP for Personal Privacy 5.0
Charset: noconv

iQA/AwUBNEG8mu0580gyByN0EQKKLgCaAk0TN/ZgvyjTtylEapvS16ZRKsIAoIts
o1BvEeNEJVD/IcoTXS4mEtba
=377L
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----


Mark et. al.:

I have run into several consultants and organizations running these 
Security reviews.  Generally, from what I've seen they fall into 4 
distinct classes: 
        1) the wannabe hacker who checks his/her one and only area of
                of "expertiese" by looking at logs, router access lists
                etc.  No real substance, no indepth knowledge of more than
                one or two platforms.  Generally no reporting to management
                other than some sort of "blessing" that will make you feel
                good if you want to believe it.
        2) The specialized consultant who runs a complete set of tools 
against
                the network such as ISS, Milkyway Audit, Kane, etc. They 
                tend to be pretty good internal audits of the platforms,
                firewall(s), routers, etc.  They usually produce at least
                an acceptable report to management with recommendations.
        3) The "big guys" (i.e, Anderson, Deloit & Touche, Earnst & Young)
                etc who bring in a team and do a pretty thorough job, albeit
                at a pretty good sized cost.  They run not only commonly
                available tools such as (2) above, but also have some very
                specialized tools they have developed internally.  They
                generally provide a very extensive report which goes to
                top management and include an oral presentation at the 
                CEO, CIO, or Board level along with all the recommended
                fixes to the problem.  

There is a 4th level also...this would be a group like "WheelGroup" 
which performs not only internal but also perimeter testing as well. 
It is conducted with teams of individuals with indepth understanding 
of Network Security.  WheelGroup calls theirs a "Security Posture 
Assessment" deriving it's roots from military experience.  Now, I'm 
not in any way associated with WheelGroup, but I have seen some of 
thier work in a previous life, and I'm impressed with what they can 
do.  I've also seen some of the "wannabe" work...you get what you pay 
for.  I've talked to people who have had the "big guys" in, and 
generally heard favorable things, however they tend to be very rigid 
in what they can check based on a pre-existing set understandings 
they have.  I've heard it said that if you throw something new at 
them they weren't expecting, you generally get a blank stare.  

FWIW, I think a combination of (2) and (3) or WheelGroup is a potent 
weapon. Let (3) or WheelGroup do the initial, then use (2) for 
routine followup audits as conditions warrant.  Every couple of years 
OR when you have significant network changes, start over with (3) or 
WG again. 

Most "complete" audits will take several days to complete and will 
require many hours of preparation, such as providing network maps, 
complete policy documentation, meetings with legal council, MIS, and 
executive staff, etc. before the actual assessment (audit) actually 
begins.  Not an undertaking for the "cash impaired" or the "feel good 
all over" level some companies are looking for.  

Comments welcome - Flames Ignored!


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: PGP for Personal Privacy 5.0
Charset: noconv

iQA/AwUBNEJdyNIk6V3CiVjTEQLMCwCgkwulP4kKxCxof9VjcXI6uEGupIIAn3Zd
uzbE5B+9hwMRZr2kL/nzwMsO
=8NVX
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

***********************************************************************
* Check out http://www.milkyway.com for the best in network security! *
*   Steve Kruse  <jsk347 () worldnet att net>  PGP Key on most servers   *
* PGP Fingerprint: 4BBF 43D2 69A4 E111 3089  C54B D224 E95D C289 58D3 *
***********************************************************************



Current thread: