Firewall Wizards mailing list archives
Re: PUBLIC: boxed "multi-purpose" firewalls - overkill??
From: peter.vaterlaus () ubs com
Date: Wed, 14 Oct 1998 17:47:28 +0200
Michael,
IMO a bastion host usually uses a single NIC only. Therfore only
application gateways can be implemented there. Most 'boxed' firewalls
are designed with multiple NICs and a distinction between 'secure',
i.e. intranet, and 'insecure' NICs. The rules then apply either in the
direction from 'insecure' to 'secure' side or opposite.
For this type FWs you need a design router <--> FW <--> router.
Depending on your security requirements and your firewall you can also
omit one or both of the routers.
Wheter you require a 'pass through' FW or one or more 'classical'
bastion hosts or a mix of all of them depends mainly on:
1) the security requirements (policy)
2) the applications (IP-protocols)
and in most cases also on the experience and preferences of the FW
designer of course!
If you are not very experienced in FW implementations, I recommend you
a multiple NIC solution. But as mentioned above, it finally depends on
your requirements.
Regards
Peter Vaterlaus
Note: I speak here for my own, not for my employer
______________________________ Reply Separator _________________________________
Subject: PUBLIC: boxed "multi-purpose" firewalls - overkill??
Author: mjd at zhux/DD.RFC-822=mjd () interaxon gr
Date: 14.10.98 15:47
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
hi all
I am putting together a firewall, only on paper for now, and a few
questions concerning the usefulness of boxed "muti-purpose" firewall
products have surfaced. I hope some of you guys can give me your
thoughts on the matter.
suppose...
I have set up a screened network architecture firewall which is
connected to the internet via an ISDN router (a baynetworks clam), and
then this dmz is connected to my internal network via a packet
filtering router (suggestions most welcome). Ok, so now I need a
bastion host to proxy my smtp, dns, and WWW. So I think .. the client
wants ease of use and reporting etc etc, has to be NT based, they have
no nix skills at all.. so what about a boxed NT firewall product .. ok
I say, how about Eagle (as everyone else is on about FW-1, and I like
to be different), it does all I want and more.. packet filtering.. but
I am sat here wondering why do I need this packet filtering? I
certainly dont want to combine this bastion host with my choke router.
Perhaps I could put it after my ISDN router, but is this really
neccessary?
So I am wondering why spend big bucks on a "multi-purpose" firewall
package like Eagle is it only for the reporting capabilities?
i would be interested in hearing how others see the use of these
products.
mike
- ----------------------------------------------
Michael J. Dilworth Interaxon ltd.
8 Rizariou St.
tel:(+301)6801013/4 Halandri
Fax:(+301)6801015 15233 Athens
Greece
- ----------------------------------------------
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: PGPfreeware 5.5.3i for non-commercial use <http://www.pgpi.com>
iQA/AwUBNiSRX26RYzC+RAvaEQKgeQCg8CG8pL7tZ13PIsH0IPsJFhvx3IoAoJFG
8B32OrGgwnz3JV2pGPtGq73K
=Gf+0
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Current thread:
- boxed "multi-purpose" firewalls - overkill?? mjd (Oct 14)
- Re: PUBLIC: boxed "multi-purpose" firewalls - overkill?? peter . vaterlaus (Oct 14)
- Re: PUBLIC: boxed "multi-purpose" firewalls - overkill?? Joseph S. D. Yao (Oct 16)
- Re: PUBLIC: Re: PUBLIC: boxed "multi-purpose" firewalls - peter . vaterlaus (Oct 16)
- Re: PUBLIC: boxed "multi-purpose" firewalls - overkill?? Joseph S. D. Yao (Oct 16)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- RE: boxed "multi-purpose" firewalls - overkill?? Noller, Gregory (Oct 14)
- Re: PUBLIC: boxed "multi-purpose" firewalls - overkill?? peter . vaterlaus (Oct 14)
