Firewall Wizards mailing list archives

Re: How secure are (cisco) ACL's?


From: Stu Allen <stu () cinops xerox com>
Date: Thu, 1 Oct 1998 08:36:18 -0400 (EDT)

In a discussion I had with a co-worker, I expressed my opinion that
Firewall1 bounded by two routers (choke/gate/choke) was probably a better
solution than a PIX front-ended by a single router (choke/gate).

I would tend to agree with that.
 
His response was that ACL's on the front-ended PIX would be sufficient
security.  In fact, he stated, a single router with comprehensive ACL's
would be sufficient for low-bandwidth internet connections.

Hmmm.  Not on MY network, thank you!
 
On the surface, it does seem that NAT in conjunction with comprehensive
ACL's is secure.  However, I have read about stateful inspection(not well
implemented on cisco) and know that this can be a problem when depending on
ACL's to do the job.

With my limited knowledge I was not able to argue my point.  Can someone
explain and/or point me to material I can digest and come back swinging in
my next encounter like this?  Also, I need to read up on choke/gate/choke
and other security architectures.  Any guiding shove in the right direction
will be deeply appreciated.

IMHO Cisco router ACLs are quite secure, although it is somewhere between
art and black magic to get them implemented correctly.  That is one of their
weak points -- they are difficult to do right, and if done wrong are worse
than nothing -- you have the _illusion_ of security.

A couple other things come to mind:

1)  There are some things that are very difficult to do "right" with ACLs.
The best example I can think of is the FTP data connection, where you often
end up having to allow any TCP >1023 to connect to port 20 ....

2)  An even scarier problem is the issue of bugs in the code.  If I am not
mistaken, there was an IOS release about 1-2 years ago where under some
circumstances the ACL could get inverted, so suddenly all your "permits"
became denies and "denies" became permits ....

This is why I also subscribe to the router/FW/router theory ....  Plus it
keeps the "bad guys" away from your firewall for the most part.

As far as reading material, have you read Cheswick & Bellovin and the O'Reilly
firewall books?
-- 
Stu Allen             Phone: (716) 231-0073
EDS / GNS             Internet: stu () cinops xerox com



Current thread: