Firewall Wizards mailing list archives

Re: Dialup vs. VPN


From: "James Moore" <jim () bokler com>
Date: Wed, 30 Sep 1998 08:49:12 -0500

Both can be operated securely. In my experience the real 
discriminator for dial-up vs VPN is cost. Cost factors tend to favor 
the VPN approach if you have a lot of users that need access from 
"long-distance" locations. Long-distance toll charges can be 
avoided if your users can dial an ISP with a POP located in the 
cities to which they travel. I'm less clear on the economics of VPN 
vs. dial-up for local connections, but I suspect that VPNs may win 
again... you'd have to trade off the costs of local telco service and 
modems against the costs of VPN software deployment.

VPNs and dial-up are definitely not mutually exclusive, but 
supporting both demands more resources. As a recommendation: 
call around and get prices for all the products and services required 
to implement both solutions, plug these numbers in a spreadsheet, 
and calculate fixed and recurring costs. Pick a winner, and then 
decide whether the loser (more expensive) approach offers anything 
to justify its implementation in a "supporting" or backup role. These 
results may be used to get management support, or CYA in the 
event that you're asked to justify your design in the future.

Best Regards,
James Moore

Hi all,

 I am trying to look at the pros and cons of running a bank of dialup
 modems
with the Cisco radius authentication vs. VPN setups in conjunction with
our firewall.  My thought is that it may be best to run a combination of
both. What are the security implications?  Should they be viewed as
mutually exclusive?  What is happening in the real world?

 Any comments, views, or pointers would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks,
Gary


Gary Scheel                                           gscheel () pps k12 or us
    Phone (503) 916-3158
Portland Public Schools                                       Fax     (503) 916-3000

"Knowing is not enough; we must apply. Willing is not enough; we must "   
- Goethe





...................................................
:   Bokler Software Corp.                         :
:   PO Box 261                                    :
:   Huntsville, AL  35804                         :
:   tel: 256-539-9901                             :
:   fax: 256-539-9313                             :
:   www: http://www.bokler.com/                   :
...................................................



Current thread: