Firewall Wizards mailing list archives

RE: CISSP


From: kstephe6 () csc com
Date: Thu, 29 Nov 2001 12:48:16 -0600

I think the thing most folks miss about the CISSP is the idea of a
"baseline" of understanding of all 10 domains in the ISC2 "Common Body of
Knowledge"  This is the list of domains from Micki Krause and Hal Tipton's
1999 book:

Access Control Systems and Methodology
Telecommunications and Network Security
Business Continuity Planning and Disaster Recovery Planning
Security Management Practices
Security Architecture and Models
Law, Investigation and Ethics
Application and Systems Development Security
Cryptography
Computer Operations Security
Physical Security

With any certification exam you can only test for a specific level of
knowledge on a finite number of questions limited by the time allowed for
the exam.   The CISSP is a test of "baseline" understanding of these 10
security domains.  That's why you have the 3 year work requirement.  It
helps to get a well-rounded security body that can handle whatever pops up.

We live in a world of never enough funding, not enough staff, special
projects, sick time and vacations.  Smaller organizations suffer from the
inability to silo their staff into specific security specialties due to
cost constraints.  Larger organizations want managers over multiple silo
structures or the entire security organization.  That is how I got my
CISSP.   A V.P. in a prior company said he would like to have a
certification on my position.  It did not change my 20 years of experience
or my ability to do my job.  It did change my salary by 15% because I did
the work to take and pass the test and my management thought that was
important.

I did some work awhile back on the ISC2 "Common Body of Knowledge" 2 week
review course materials.  I doubt there are many who subscribe to this list
who could not learn something useful from the review course.  Yes you will
be bored listening to the parts you already know.  The review course is
substantially better when you take it with a group that asks lots of
questions.  (That loud yelling in the background is Hal Tipton cursing my
name to the heavens for that remark)   Having a crypto expert and a
firewall expert in the crowd also makes the review more enlightening.

My point is you evaluate people as a whole.  A CISSP with 3 years
experience should be a better body to improve security in a small
organization over most people with 3 years experience who did not get the
cert.  That is not a guaranty that allows a hiring manager to go brain dead
and skip the normal interview/background process.  If you need a manager to
manage multiple domains in your security department, a CISSP has already
proven a "baseline" understanding of all 10 domains.  The CISSP will have a
clear advantage in that hiring situation over most non-CISSP candidates.

To make any certification a negative thing is stereotyping the work that
good people are doing to try and better themselves and our industry.  The
clueless should get weeded out during the normal interview/background
process, certified or not.


Ken Stephens, CISSP
Sr. Security Manager
Computer Sciences Corporation
One Tower Lane, Suite 400
Oakbrook Terrace, IL 60181
Voice:  630.990.6207

<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<reply
separator>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>



                                                                                                     
                    Jeff Brown                                                                       
                    <jvbrown () gte net>          To:     "Jody C. Patilla" <jcp01 () attglobal net>, t    
                    Sent by:                    <miedaner () twcny rr com>                              
                    firewall-wizards-adm       cc:     firewall-wizards () nfr com                      
                    in () nfr com                 Subject:     RE: [fw-wiz] CISSP                       
                                                                                                     
                                                                                                     
                    11/28/01 11:59 AM                                                                
                                                                                                     
                                                                                                     





It's likely that this thread will run open-loop
on fw-wiz, as this is more akin to an enigma.

These questions and responses bring to mind
similar long running debates on real-world vs.
theoretical experience. While few would argue
that 'cockpit' expertise is important in gaining a
true understanding of the InfoSec issues, the
existence of some minimum standard (CISSP or
other) is necessary to establish a starting point.

We have all seen and understand the difference
between a certified newbie Novell/Microsoft/other
'gurus', and the individuals that are so busy doing
the WORK, they have little time/interest in a cert.

Generally, the cert seems to be most important
to those interested in Resume building...
these days, an increasingly significant motivator.

Heck,  I wonder what % of BlackHats (some
of which are as skilled in these elements as any
whitehat) need a CISSP behind their handle ?

My sense is that most hiring entities would opt
for a PROVEN cockpit expert anyday.

JVBrown



_______________________________________________
firewall-wizards mailing list
firewall-wizards () nfr com
http://list.nfr.com/mailman/listinfo/firewall-wizards


Current thread: