Firewall Wizards mailing list archives
Re: How to Save The World (was: Antivirus vendor conspiracy theories)
From: "Paul D. Robertson" <paul () compuwar net>
Date: Sun, 12 Dec 2004 12:18:47 -0500 (EST)
On Wed, 8 Dec 2004, Marcus J. Ranum wrote:
Devdas Bhagat ruthlessly trolls for rants with this bait:
And it worked...
Then users need to accept a small bit of slowing down as the cost of security.That is just so much boolah and we all know it.
Unfortunately, it would appear that many of the collective us don't know it...
"Performance" is the first money-wrench that users reach for when they are trying to come up with an excuse to blockade security. I have yet to run into
I've had it tried on my more times than I can count. Where it was an active concern, I provided some sort of measurement to executive management- however- my better and standard answer was to point out that security was *mandated* by the *policy* for what they wanted to do, so if they wanted to do it _faster_, I'd be happy to spec out faster machines and more networking gear to meet their requirements should they wish to budget for it. Not one single taker. Ever.
an instance where someone who has complained about "poor performance" has ever backed it up with measurements. (Except for the instances where performance was *zero* because someone unplugged a firewall, or put a "block all" rule in place) I've seen cases where users didn't realize they were behind one of those "slow" proxy firewalls until someone told them. Then, of course, it was "too slow" and had to be taken out.
I got that once- switched a good-sized organization over to a new proxy firewall - whine, whine, whine, until they learned that they'd been *sharing* a slower system with another organization for several years, and now they had 1/2 the users and probably 5x the system resources. Half-clued admins are fun to LART.
That's not to say that various security implimentations don't have some kind of performance impact! I'm sure that they do. What honks me off, however, is that the performance argument is widely accepted in spite of the fact that it's never measured. In the absence of measures, one might as well use feng shui or dowsing as a means of designing one's network - it's just as scientific.
I abhor measurement, and always try to budget for enough capacity that I don't have to do it until I'm near the end of the lifecycle.
"You must install a proxy firewall this week; the moon is in the 3rd house and the router is ascendant. That means that since
I don't like Ascend routers :-P
our T1 goes north-south we need to sacrifice 3 black roosters to keep the hackers out."
Or you could just get on the fiber ring... circles have more natural energy... Paul ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- Paul D. Robertson "My statements in this message are personal opinions paul () compuwar net which may have no basis whatsoever in fact." _______________________________________________ firewall-wizards mailing list firewall-wizards () honor icsalabs com http://honor.icsalabs.com/mailman/listinfo/firewall-wizards
Current thread:
- Re: How to Save The World, (continued)
- Re: How to Save The World Bruce B. Platt (Dec 13)
- Re: How to Save The World (was: Antivirus vendor conspiracy theories) Marcus J. Ranum (Dec 12)
- Re: How to Save The World Crispin Cowan (Dec 13)
- Re: How to Save The World (was: Antivirus vendor conspiracy theories) ucxfoe (Dec 15)
- Re: Re: How to Save The World (was: Antivirus vendor conspiracy theories) Devdas Bhagat (Dec 15)
- Re: Re: How to Save The World (was: Antivirus vendor conspiracy theories) Marcus J. Ranum (Dec 16)
- Re: Re: How to Save The World (was: Antivirus vendor conspiracy theories) Adam Shostack (Dec 19)
- Re: How to Save The World (was: Antivirus vendor conspiracy theories) Harry Tabak (Dec 15)
- Re: How to Save The World (was: Antivirus vendor conspiracy theories) ucxfoe (Dec 15)
- Re: How to Save The World (was: Antivirus vendor conspiracy theories) Marcus J. Ranum (Dec 11)
- Re: How to Save The World (was: Antivirus vendor conspiracy theories) Paul D. Robertson (Dec 12)
- Re: How to Save The World (was: Antivirus vendor conspiracy theories) Jim Seymour (Dec 12)
- Re: How to Save The World (was: Antivirus vendor conspiracy theories) Chris Pugrud (Dec 13)
