Firewall Wizards mailing list archives
RE: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry
From: Steffen Kluge <kluge () fujitsu com au>
Date: Mon, 08 Nov 2004 16:40:49 +1100
Before responding to Bill's post, let me say that this whole thread (and its almost unison tenor) has left me completely gobsmacked and disenchanted about the professionalism in our profession. On Fri, 2004-11-05 at 22:45 -0500, Bill Royds wrote:
One of the problems that giving such publicity to so many criminal "ex-hackers" is that it makes it much more difficult for honest security practitioners to do our job.
I've had the exact opposite experience. Me and a few of my colleagues have fought over the years for every little bit of recognition of the role of IT security in our environments. It has been a very hard sell, to say the least, not to a small degree due to the fact that we tried to do the right thing regardless of under-funding, hence preventing show-case incidents on our own time. Among the few things we've found to be effective in sharpening management's attention to security issues is non-technical decision makers attending conferences featuring colourful speakers that are able to illustrate first-hand (as in "been there done that") the dangers of complacency in the IT security field. This has helped more security projects/budgets along than any of our lobbying could ever have done.
But the very fact that I had this ability made me suspect in some people's eyes.
I've never broken into any computer unlawfully myself, but I can't help finding this assertion anywhere between the amusing and the ridiculous. Have we suddenly turned into a bunch of evangelists, or are we still engaged in the intellectual arms race IT security used to be? Kind of like the locksmith refusing to learn from the lock-picker... Before you say it, no, I don't think mjr's depiction of Mitnick as a clown flogging his criminal past is accurate in this context. If he was a clown he'd have nothing to say and we'd have nothing to learn from him. I don't think that's the case. I've seen enough clowns in suits and respectable jobs (without criminal record - or any record whatsoever), speaking on various conferences, to believe that those warez-peddling charlatans have damaged our profession for generations. And yes, I think I've learned a fair bit from reading "The Art of Deception", probably more so than from "The Myth of Homeland Security", although I enjoyed that, too. I don't mind political correctness per se, but if it is used to suppress the dissemination of real insight in an area we're supposed to be on top of, then I'd have to say, stick it.
Their attitude becomes "You know how computer systems work so you must have learned that by criminal hacking like all those hackers in the news".
This is where your post turns self-referential. Since you didn't allow yourself to study the enemy by reading their memoirs (let alone allowing them to your conferences) you must have been a criminal mind yourself. That is, unless you believe that...
This is despite a university degree in computer science and 30 years worth of experience in computers.
... gives you sufficient insight into understanding the drivers and motivations that make hackers show up at *your* of all IP addresses in the world. Please forget your sour grapes for a moment and take your intelligence from wherever you can (legally) get it. (Note that I didn't made any reference to Abagnale, I simply don't know enough about the man to even have an opinion. This post is more about the thread that unfolded after the OP.) Cheers Steffen.
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part
Current thread:
- Re: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Stephen P. Berry (Nov 02)
- Re: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Paul D. Robertson (Nov 02)
- Re: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Adam Shostack (Nov 02)
- Re: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Christopher Hicks (Nov 04)
- RE: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Bill Royds (Nov 07)
- RE: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Mark Teicher (Nov 07)
- Hacker Repellant - was RE: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Marcus J. Ranum (Nov 08)
- RE: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Jim Seymour (Nov 07)
- RE: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry David Lang (Nov 08)
- RE: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Steffen Kluge (Nov 08)
- Re: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry ArkanoiD (Nov 12)
- Re: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Christopher Hicks (Nov 04)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Margles (Nov 04)
- RE: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Melson, Paul (Nov 10)
- Re: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry ArkanoiD (Nov 12)
- Re[2]: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry gmx (Nov 13)
- Re[2]: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Paul D. Robertson (Nov 13)
- Re[2]: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry gmx (Nov 13)
- Re: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry ArkanoiD (Nov 12)
- Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Mike Smith (Nov 12)
- Re: Re: Ethics, morality and the industry Gwendolynn ferch Elydyr (Nov 12)
