Full Disclosure mailing list archives
RE: PGPNet Upgrade path ?
From: "Aditya Deshmukh" <aditya.deshmukh () online gateway strangled net>
Date: Sun, 18 Sep 2005 08:03:37 +0530
gem () rellim com Wrote :
IPSEC has nothing to do with PGP. Also there is really no such thing as a PGP key. PGP uses what ever key scheme you ask it to use. IPSEC is the same way. Both use keys, but are not themselves key standards. OpenVPN similarly can use what ever key scheme you wish. Since it is based on the OpenSSL crupto libs it is very flexible that way. For simple setups you can use pre-shared keys. For more complex setups you can use public/private key pairs of any type that OpenSSL understands.
This is the main problem - how do I get PGP key server keys in a format Openssl understand ? And I have implemented CA and ipsec vpn using freeSWAN.org + x.509 patch it works pretty nicely, but here in this case the public/private KEYs are in a different format...
IMHO, if OpenVPN does not do what you want then you misunderstand the problem.
The problem is very clear : how do I tranlate PGP keys to a format X.509 / openssl can understand ? I havent a solution to this one yet. m () rtij nl Wrote :
I know for ipsec VPNs I could use the winxp's builtin But that would require moving all the PGP keys to X.509 certs.Yes, absolutely. For OpenVPN you need to use X509 certs, you will have to rework your whole PKI. However:
I have already used openvpn and (free|open|whatever)swan, have created openssl CA with batch files that run both on windows and linux/freebsd/solaris at other sites.... All these programs are great in own right but I cannot connect the Dots.
So if you consider dropping PGP all together, have a look at OpenVPN.
This is the last option. If nothing is found then it is going to be openvpn But meanwhile I need a VPN that uses PGP keys for auth that are stored in PGP Key Server, does not matter If it free or paid but if anyone know that There is such a program please let me know.... Thank you in advance for the time taken to dig out the answers :) ________________________________________________________________________ Delivered using the Free Personal Edition of Mailtraq (www.mailtraq.com)
Attachment:
smime.p7s
Description:
_______________________________________________ Full-Disclosure - We believe in it. Charter: http://lists.grok.org.uk/full-disclosure-charter.html Hosted and sponsored by Secunia - http://secunia.com/
Current thread:
- PGPNet Upgrade path ? Aditya Deshmukh (Sep 13)
- Re: PGPNet Upgrade path ? Martijn Lievaart (Sep 16)
- RE: PGPNet Upgrade path ? Aditya Deshmukh (Sep 16)
- RE: PGPNet Upgrade path ? Gary E. Miller (Sep 16)
- Re: PGPNet Upgrade path ? Martijn Lievaart (Sep 17)
- RE: PGPNet Upgrade path ? Aditya Deshmukh (Sep 17)
- RE: PGPNet Upgrade path ? Martijn Lievaart (Sep 23)
- RE: PGPNet Upgrade path ? Aditya Deshmukh (Sep 16)
- Re: PGPNet Upgrade path ? Martijn Lievaart (Sep 16)
