Interesting People mailing list archives

IP: Re: Washington's racism and the Islamist trap -- not pleasant reading but ..


From: David Farber <dave () farber net>
Date: Mon, 24 Sep 2001 06:44:45 -0400


X-Sender: jcamp () camail1 harvard edu
Date: Mon, 24 Sep 2001 05:21:59 +0100
To: farber () cis upenn edu
From: Jean Camp <jean_camp () harvard edu>
Subject: Re: IP: Washington's racism and the Islamist trap -- not pleasant
   reading but ..

Women want to work, have access to health care, and not be murdered brutally if any man cares to point his finger at her. We would like to feed our children and see our girls learn how to read.

I do not think believing that no woman gives birth thinking, "Please let this child die a suicidal death in hopeless nihilistic hatred." is a

"classic case history in cultural stupidity." or "unwarranted contempt for its Islamist adversary"

SHE matters too, something IP and American foreign policy forget.

Pakistan mattered, and Afghanistan mattered so we had REAL POLITICS. None of that silly sixties garbage --> REAL POLITICS so we can have NATIONAL SECURITY.

Bangladesh was a waste case left to the NGOs. Now Bangladesh has a birthrate of <3 children/family rising literacy and real elections. Because the Muslim, SHE cares about her children too. Afghanistan is a nightmare and Pakistan has the sixth (?) military distator we have supported there. We have spent real money on real politics in those states, with REALLY bad results.

Looks like Spengler is the blind one here.

-Jean


At 9:01 am -0400 9/23/01, David Farber wrote:
Washington's racism and the Islamist trap

By Spengler

"The Arab is a patriot, not a whore," the hardline Zionist leader Vladimir Jabotinsky used to warn his leftwing colleagues back during the 1920s. "He can't be bought off by the promise of economic benefits. And he is just as intelligent as you are."

Implicit in America's pompous elocution against terrorism is a Kiplingesque premise that it is carrying the White Man's Burden to the underprivileged Middle East and South Asia. Except for a few "fundamentalist" recalcitrants, Washington believes, everyone in those parts of the world wants what the US wants: suburban tract housing developments, video on demand, fast food, egalitarianism and economic opportunity. It has put the Taliban on its "Wanted: Dead or Alive" poster, because the Taliban are an irrelevant medieval relic that fits a racist profile. Indeed, President Bush's silly ultimatim to the Taliban in his speech before Congress of September 20 might enter the textbooks as the classic case history in cultural stupidity. America's unwarranted contempt for its Islamist adversary already has had terrible consequences, and well might have catastrophic ones.

http://www.atimes.com/front/CI22Aa02.html



For archives see: http://www.interesting-people.org/


--




For archives see: http://www.interesting-people.org/


Current thread: