nanog mailing list archives

Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy...


From: Mark Andrews <Mark_Andrews () isc org>
Date: Wed, 15 Aug 2007 11:58:52 +1000 (EST)


This comment was added as a follow-on note.  Sorry for not being clear.

Accepting messages from a domain lacking MX records might be risky  
due to the high rate of domain turnovers.  Within a few weeks, more  
than the number of existing domains will have been added and deleted  
by then.  Spammers take advantage of this flux.  Unfortunately SMTP  
server discovery via A records is permitted and should be  
deprecated.  

        All it would require is a couple of large ISP's to adopt
        such a policy.  "MX 0 <self>" really is not hard and benefits
        the remote caches.

Once MX records are adopted as an _acceptance_  
requisite, domains not intended to receive or send email would be  
clearly denoted by the absence of MX records.  SMTP policy published  
adjacent to MX records also eliminates a need for email policy  
"discovery" as well.  Another looming problem.

        Better yet us MX records to signal that you don't want to
        receive email e.g. "MX 0 .".  It has a additional benefits
        in that it is *much* smaller to cache than a negative
        response.  It's also smaller to cache than a A record.

        Since all valid email domains are required to have a working
        postmaster you can safely drop any email from such domains.

Don't accept a message from a domain without MX records.  When there  
is no policy record adjacent to the MX record, there is no policy,  
and don't go looking.

-Doug




Current thread: