nanog mailing list archives

RE: 240/4


From: <michael.dillon () bt com>
Date: Thu, 18 Oct 2007 23:34:48 +0100



Consider an auto company network. behind firewalls and having  
thousands and thousands of robots and other factory floor 
machines.   
Most of these have IPv4 stacks that barely function and would never 
function on IPv6.  One company estimated that they needed 
40 million 
addresses for this purpose.

I guess I have a certain amount of skepticism that an auto 
company's robotic control network needs to have public IP addresses.

Of course they don't need public addresses, but they do need to have
non-private globally unique IP addresses.

And RFC 2050 does allow such companies to go to an RIR and get an
allocation of globally unique IPv4 addresses. You may not have noticed
it, but IP addresses are *NOT* Internet addresses, they are
internet-protocol addresses, and can be used on or off the Internet
wherever IP stacks are used.

--Michael Dillon


Current thread: