nanog mailing list archives

Re: IP Address Management IPAM software for small ISP


From: Thilo Bangert <thilo.bangert () gmail com>
Date: Thu, 20 Dec 2012 10:30:02 +0100

On Thursday 20 December 2012 09:11:43 Saku Ytti wrote:
On (2012-12-20 03:24 +0000), Blake Pfankuch wrote:
I actually was doing research on this today as well.  Anyone have any
experience with the solutions that implement VLAN management as well like
Gestioip?
I'm not remotely interested in externally developed software for this
problem. 

what do you mean. i'd be fine with an opensource project providing this.

But it's fair question. Generally this tool should not be IP or
VLAN based but generic resource reservation tool, IP, VLAN, RD, RT,
VPLS-ID, site-id, pseudowireID what have you.

For me, humans would not do much directly with the tool. They'd give it
large chunk of resource. Then maybe mine it to pools like 'coreLink',
'coreLoop', 'custLink', 'custLAN' etc.
Then in your provisioning tools, you'd request resource from specific pool
via restful API. Humand would never manually write RD/RT/IP/VLAN in the
tool or in the configs. And this type of system is vastly simpler than the
IPAMs I see listed, once you get rid of all the UI candy, it gets rather
easy problem to solve.

this is a pretty accurate description of our requirements, as well. off the 
top of my head we'd also manage phone numbers, key ids, and key box ids, with 
it, but that would almost be a minor detail. ;-)




Current thread: