nanog mailing list archives

Re: [c-nsp] DNS amplification


From: Jimmy Hess <mysidia () gmail com>
Date: Sun, 17 Mar 2013 21:04:26 -0500

On 3/17/13, Jon Lewis <jlewis () lewis org> wrote:
On Sun, 17 Mar 2013, Arturo Servin wrote:

You'd have to get access (cloud VM, dedicated server, etc.) on each
network and see if you can successfully get spoofed packets out to
another network.

If you have packet data about a sufficient number of different kinds
of attacks per source network over a long period of time, at a
specific attack/normal traffic sensor;  you might be able to infer
some information about  which networks  prevent spoofing,  through  a
difference in the kind of attacks shown to be originating from all the
networks.

If spoofing is preferred, or used by other nodes involved in a
particular attack,  the networks that are concentrated sources of
non-spoofing attack packets most likely, are places where  spoofing
prevention could be present -- and have altered attacker behavior.


Possibly the presence of spoofed packets may be suggested by a sudden
drastic difference in the average TTL versus legitimate traffic for a
particular source network for packets with a particular source IP,
correlated with the attack  VS the  remaining packet TTLs  normally
observed for legitimate traffic  from that network.

If you have a sufficiently massive number of traffic sensors, and
massive data gathering infrastructure,  close enough to the attacks,
it may be possible to analyze the microsecond-level timing of packets,
and the time sequence/order they arrive at various sensors
(milliseconds delay/propagation rate of attacker nodes initiating),
in order to provide a probability that spoofed packets came from
certain networks.

Then at that point, you might make some  guesses about which networks
implement BCP38

--
-JH


Current thread: