nanog mailing list archives

Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification]


From: Mark Andrews <marka () isc org>
Date: Thu, 21 Mar 2013 07:44:06 +1100


In message <59415DCC-2D4E-4DD9-87C9-0B56BF24FCCF () ianai net>, "Patrick W. Gilmor
e" writes:
On Mar 20, 2013, at 09:25 , Owen DeLong <owen () delong com> wrote:

I don't know a single ISP that wants to throttle growth by not =
accepting additional customers, BGP speaking or not. (I do know several =
that want to throttle growth through not upgrading their links because =
they have a captive audience they are trying to ransom. But that is =
neither relevant to this discussion, not controversial - unless you are =
paid by one of those ISPs=85.)
=20
Comcast
Verizon
AT&T
Time Warner Cable
Cox
CenturyLink
=20
to name a few.
=20
Not one of them will run BGP with a residential subscriber.

Who cares? [See below.]


And please don't reply with "then why can't I run BGP on my =
[cable|DSL|etc.] link?" Broadband providers are not trying to throttle =
growth by not allowing grandma to do BGP, and swapping to LISP or =
anything else won't change that.
=20
Sure they are. If they weren't, it would be relatively straight =
forward to add the necessary options to DHCP for a minimal (accept =
default, advertise local) BGP configuration and it would be quite simple =
for CPE router manufacturers to incorporate those capabilities.
=20
The problem is BGP doesn't scale to that level and everyone knows it, =
so, we limit growth by not allowing it to be a possibility.

This is patently false. No network has a decision matrix that is "BGP =
doesn't scale, so let's refuse money from customers".

Every single one of the companies you listed will run BGP with =
customers. You limited this to "residential subscriber". Companies do =
not have only "residential customers". Pay more, get more. Pay $40, get =
less. Shocker.

"Not if you don't pay for it" is not a valid argument against "every =
$COMPANY has $FEATURE".

I said the barrier to entry for multihoming was lower than it has ever =
been. I didn't say it was zero.


You are a pretty smart guy, so I'm going to give you the benefit of the =
doubt and assume you just kinda-sortta forgot or did not consider the =
whole "money" thing, despite the fact the only reason nearly every =
Internet entity exists. (Now I wonder how many people are going to tell =
me about the N% which are non-profits, despite the fact I said =
"nearly"?)

--=20
TTFN,
patrick

And homenet at the IETF demonstrated multi-homed residential
connections with IPv6 without NAT using multiple PA addresses.  If
a upsteam goes down the connections over that upstream break.  New
connection use the working upstream.  It's not quite the same as
using PI but it is a 99.9% solution.

Mark
-- 
Mark Andrews, ISC
1 Seymour St., Dundas Valley, NSW 2117, Australia
PHONE: +61 2 9871 4742                 INTERNET: marka () isc org


Current thread: