nanog mailing list archives
Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification]
From: Mark Andrews <marka () isc org>
Date: Thu, 21 Mar 2013 07:44:06 +1100
In message <59415DCC-2D4E-4DD9-87C9-0B56BF24FCCF () ianai net>, "Patrick W. Gilmor e" writes:
On Mar 20, 2013, at 09:25 , Owen DeLong <owen () delong com> wrote:I don't know a single ISP that wants to throttle growth by not =accepting additional customers, BGP speaking or not. (I do know several = that want to throttle growth through not upgrading their links because = they have a captive audience they are trying to ransom. But that is = neither relevant to this discussion, not controversial - unless you are = paid by one of those ISPs=85.)=20 Comcast Verizon AT&T Time Warner Cable Cox CenturyLink =20 to name a few. =20 Not one of them will run BGP with a residential subscriber.Who cares? [See below.]And please don't reply with "then why can't I run BGP on my =[cable|DSL|etc.] link?" Broadband providers are not trying to throttle = growth by not allowing grandma to do BGP, and swapping to LISP or = anything else won't change that.=20 Sure they are. If they weren't, it would be relatively straight =forward to add the necessary options to DHCP for a minimal (accept = default, advertise local) BGP configuration and it would be quite simple = for CPE router manufacturers to incorporate those capabilities.=20 The problem is BGP doesn't scale to that level and everyone knows it, =so, we limit growth by not allowing it to be a possibility. This is patently false. No network has a decision matrix that is "BGP = doesn't scale, so let's refuse money from customers". Every single one of the companies you listed will run BGP with = customers. You limited this to "residential subscriber". Companies do = not have only "residential customers". Pay more, get more. Pay $40, get = less. Shocker. "Not if you don't pay for it" is not a valid argument against "every = $COMPANY has $FEATURE". I said the barrier to entry for multihoming was lower than it has ever = been. I didn't say it was zero. You are a pretty smart guy, so I'm going to give you the benefit of the = doubt and assume you just kinda-sortta forgot or did not consider the = whole "money" thing, despite the fact the only reason nearly every = Internet entity exists. (Now I wonder how many people are going to tell = me about the N% which are non-profits, despite the fact I said = "nearly"?) --=20 TTFN, patrick
And homenet at the IETF demonstrated multi-homed residential connections with IPv6 without NAT using multiple PA addresses. If a upsteam goes down the connections over that upstream break. New connection use the working upstream. It's not quite the same as using PI but it is a 99.9% solution. Mark -- Mark Andrews, ISC 1 Seymour St., Dundas Valley, NSW 2117, Australia PHONE: +61 2 9871 4742 INTERNET: marka () isc org
Current thread:
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification], (continued)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] John Curran (Mar 24)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] Leo Bicknell (Mar 25)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] Kyle Creyts (Mar 24)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] George Herbert (Mar 24)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] Owen DeLong (Mar 24)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] Valdis . Kletnieks (Mar 25)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] William Herrin (Mar 23)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] Patrick W. Gilmore (Mar 20)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] Owen DeLong (Mar 20)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] Patrick W. Gilmore (Mar 20)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] Mark Andrews (Mar 20)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] John Curran (Mar 20)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] Owen DeLong (Mar 20)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] John Curran (Mar 20)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] Owen DeLong (Mar 20)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] Jimmy Hess (Mar 22)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] William Herrin (Mar 20)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] Brielle Bruns (Mar 20)
- Re: Is multihoming hard? [was: DNS amplification] Andrew D Kirch (Mar 20)
- Re: [c-nsp] DNS amplification David Conrad (Mar 20)
- Re: [c-nsp] DNS amplification Sander Steffann (Mar 18)
