nanog mailing list archives
Re: Open Resolver Problems
From: "Dobbins, Roland" <rdobbins () arbor net>
Date: Fri, 29 Mar 2013 12:06:36 +0000
On Mar 29, 2013, at 6:58 PM, Joe Greco wrote:
Really, I've spent a disappointing amount of time listening to the "but but but you can't DOOOOOOOOO that"
What they're really worried about is folks arbitrarily deciding to permanently mask out ANY queries altogether as a matter of policy, rather than either rate-limiting them or selectively filtering them during an actual attack, and only within the scope of the servers/records being abused for that particular attack. Many measures which are not only permissible but are often vitally necessary in order to achieve partial service recovery during an attack can cause prohibitive levels of brokenness when implemented as matters of permanently-enforced policy. Given the history of such overt stupidity as blocking TCP/53, disallowing UDP DNS packets larger than 512 bytes, blocking ICMP necessary for PMTU-D, et. al., their concerns are not unreasonable. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Roland Dobbins <rdobbins () arbor net> // <http://www.arbornetworks.com> Luck is the residue of opportunity and design. -- John Milton
Current thread:
- Re: Open Resolver Problems, (continued)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Marco Davids (Mar 27)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Jared Mauch (Mar 27)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Joe Abley (Mar 27)
- Can we not just fix it? WAS:Re: Open Resolver Problems Michael DeMan (Mar 28)
- Re: Can we not just fix it? WAS:Re: Open Resolver Problems David Conrad (Mar 28)
- Re: Can we not just fix it? WAS:Re: Open Resolver Problems Saku Ytti (Mar 28)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Ben Aitchison (Mar 28)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Jimmy Hess (Mar 29)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Mark Andrews (Mar 29)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Joe Greco (Mar 29)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Dobbins, Roland (Mar 29)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Joe Greco (Mar 29)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Doug Barton (Mar 29)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Masataka Ohta (Mar 29)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Jared Mauch (Mar 26)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Valdis . Kletnieks (Mar 26)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems joel jaeggli (Mar 26)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Jay Ashworth (Mar 26)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Saku Ytti (Mar 26)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Leo Bicknell (Mar 26)
- Re: Open Resolver Problems Scott Noel-Hemming (Mar 29)
