nanog mailing list archives

Re: Best band for your buck router and switch (gigabit)


From: Jason Antman <jason () jasonantman com>
Date: Sat, 16 Nov 2013 12:15:20 -0500

If you're going to consider Mikrotik, I'd also highly recommend that you
look into Vyatta (www.vyatta.com). They offer (well, or did last time I
looked, they seem to be increasingly commercial every time I visit their
site) fully supported software as well as software-on-vendor-hardware
solutions, plus an open source "core" offering. I've never done BGP on
them, but I've used them as edge routers/firewalls for smallish internal
networks as well as IPSEC endpoints, and their performance on modern
server-grade hardware (i.e. the type of stuff lying around in many
shops) is mind-boggling.

Post Script: I just went to vyatta.com, and apparently they've been
acquired by Brocade. The former content of their web site is gone, and
as far as I can tell from the Brocade site
(http://www.brocade.com/products/all/network-functions-virtualization/index.page)
they *seem* to be calling the software solution the "Brocade Vyatta 5400
vRouter". I assume this means their range of supported hardware devices
may be done for. Luckily I kept an archive of all of their wonderful
anti-cisco ads...


-Jason

On 11/16/2013 04:45 AM, Rakesh M wrote:
Mx80 Might work if you are looking at Expansion options for future it comes
with Modular Cards or Tested Cisco 760x series might suffice as well. Other
Options like Mikrotik as above stated  might work but i myself never tested
that brand though



Rakesh


On Sat, Nov 16, 2013 at 8:44 AM, Michael Smith <mksmith () mac com> wrote:

Not sure what your budge is but you might consider the ASR1k.  Or the
Juniper MX104.

Mike

On Nov 15, 2013, at 5:49 PM, Nick Cameo <symack () gmail com> wrote:

Hello Everyone,

We are in the market for a used integrated service router and switch to
manage
our network. A 24 port gigabit switch should suffice accompanied with
an industry
grade router. We like buying used (still under warranty) equipment as
long as there
is good feedback. Which make and models are you gents and ladies liking
these
days?

Some Requirements for the router:

IPSEC and VPN Enabled
Transcoding capabilities using PVDM2 and NM-HDV2

We were considering:

Cisco 3845
Cisco WS-C2960G-24TC-L

But I thought I would get some insight on value, pricing, and
scalability before making
a recommendation.

Kind Regards,

Nick.






Current thread: