Re: Super Core Hardware suggestions

[Michael <excelsio () gmx com>]

Hello,

we´re using H3C S5820v2 (== HP 5900AF) switches for our 10Gbe servers, 
as HP won the public tender:

- 1RU
- Broadcom Trident I ASIC
- 48x 10Gbe SFP+, 4x40GbE QSFP+
- NO deep buffer (on that specific switch)
- The switch itself is inexpensive, but
- NO HP lifetime warranty. We need hardware carepacks and also purchased 
software carepacks, but
- even with a software carepack, it´s unfortunately not possible to get 
bugs fixed for years (for some older H3C device).
- We´re running OSPF+BFD, OSPFv3+BFD. (According to the datasheet, they 
can do ISIS+ISISv6 + MPLS, too - Never tested on those)
- NO "In Service Software Upgrade“ (ISSU), also not on HP´s bigger 
modular switches with redundant fabrics. As soon you have a software 
upgrade, you´re lost. If HP tells you something about "ISSU", that´s 
only for some hot patches, but I have seen only 1 within the last year 
for all of our HP/H3C devices.
- HP optics are quite expensive. But you could actually put every other 
vendor coded SFP module in it (for now) and it works. (Yes it will warn 
you within logging)
- If you need higher quantities talk to your HP representative. Cisco is 
not the only vendor that can give 70% off price list...

Btw, if I were allowed to buy something else, I´d go for Juniper...

Regards
Michael



Am 07.08.2015 um 04:10 schrieb Ben Cornish:
> Hey All
>
> We are looking for suggestions for a device to act as a super Core Device / MPLS P router only.
> There seems to be plenty of Chassis based solutions out there that also cater for a lot more.
> We ideally would like a 1RU or 2RU device - Handling MPLS / IGP only
>
> *         Ideally 16 to 48 ports of 10Gig - SFP
>
> *         Non-blocking line rate capable on all ports.
>
> *         MPLS / OSPF /BFD / ISIS / RSVP-TE capably.
>
> *         Deep buffers on the ports would also be nice
>
> *         With a possible option of 40Gig uplinks..
>
> Thanks