nanog mailing list archives
Re: UDP clamped on service provider links
From: Christopher Morrow <morrowc.lists () gmail com>
Date: Fri, 31 Jul 2015 10:35:37 -0400
On Fri, Jul 31, 2015 at 8:07 AM, John Kristoff <jtk () cymru com> wrote:
On Thu, 30 Jul 2015 21:18:10 -0500 Jason Baugher <jason () thebaughers com> wrote:In one case, when we were having an issue with a SIP trunk, we re-numbered our end to another IP in the same subnet. Same path from A to Z, but the packet loss mysteriously disappeared using the new IP. It sure seems like they are throttling somewhere.Not knowing how you evaluated the two paths, but if MPLS was not considered, it may have perhaps been due in part to ECMP behavior. While not ruling out UDP limits, it is plausible that the changed source IP address resulted in a less congested path to be chosen.
ding! this sounds like the most plausible answer... I wouldn't expect L3 to limit udp/5060/6061/SIP traffic, as a common carrier that also runs a SIP trunking service they: 1) probably know what SIP traffic is 2) don't want to get bitten being seen as preferring their own network offerings over other external ones (or perhaps accidentally impacting actual customers).
Current thread:
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links, (continued)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links John Kristoff (Jul 30)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Ted Hardie (Jul 30)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Ca By (Jul 30)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Ted Hardie (Jul 31)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Ted Hardie (Jul 30)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Jason Baugher (Jul 30)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Matt Hoppes (Jul 30)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Jason Baugher (Jul 30)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Randy Bush (Jul 30)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Brad Fleming (Jul 31)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links John Kristoff (Jul 31)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Christopher Morrow (Jul 31)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Jon Lewis (Jul 31)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links John Kristoff (Jul 30)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Tom Sands (Jul 30)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Jason Baugher (Jul 30)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Ca By (Jul 30)
- Re: UDP clamped on service provider links Jason Baugher (Jul 30)
