nanog mailing list archives
Re: Last Mile Design
From: Clayton Zekelman <clayton () MNSi Net>
Date: Sat, 09 Feb 2019 13:35:18 -0500
We have around 60,000 homes passed with GPON architecture. I'm not really sure how we would have built that with active roadside cabinets, and still have been able to maintain any sort cost control.
If we did it with a home run individual fibre scheme hauled back to a central POP, the frame would have been massive and the power and cooling requirements would have made the entire project unfeasible.
Maybe the economics are different in other markets.Because PON is so widely deployed, you can count on vendors coming up with capacity increases (NG, X, etc.) to support the installed base of infrastructure. Verizon alone will drive that market.
From a purist point of view, AE is a nice idea, but it really isn't necessary for now or the foreseeable future.
At 01:22 PM 09/02/2019, Sander Steffann wrote:
Hi Mark,> My preference, for the home, would be Active-E. But I do understand the economics that may support PON, and my position on that has softened over the years.Same for me. I like the architecture where the PON splitters are in powered roadside cabinets (even though the splitter is passive). That way the ISP can convert it to AE at any time they want. The architectures where PON has been hardcoded into the design has always felt like a huge risk regarding future developments.Cheers, Sander
-- Clayton Zekelman Managed Network Systems Inc. (MNSi) 3363 Tecumseh Rd. E Windsor, Ontario N8W 1H4 tel. 519-985-8410fax. 519-985-8409
Current thread:
- Re: Last Mile Design, (continued)
- Re: Last Mile Design Mikael Abrahamsson (Feb 11)
- Re: Last Mile Design Mark Tinka (Feb 11)
- Re: Last Mile Design Mikael Abrahamsson (Feb 11)
- Re: Last Mile Design Mark Tinka (Feb 11)
- Re: Last Mile Design Fletcher Kittredge (Feb 13)
- Re: Last Mile Design Brandon Butterworth (Feb 10)
- Re: Last Mile Design [American Operators] Fletcher Kittredge (Feb 13)
- Re: Last Mile Design Mark Tinka (Feb 10)
- Re: Last Mile Design Mark Tinka (Feb 09)
- Re: Last Mile Design Sander Steffann (Feb 09)
- Re: Last Mile Design Clayton Zekelman (Feb 09)
- Re: Last Mile Design Grant Taylor via NANOG (Feb 09)
- Re: Last Mile Design Miles Fidelman (Feb 09)
- Re: Last Mile Design Grant Taylor via NANOG (Feb 09)
- Re: Last Mile Design Baldur Norddahl (Feb 09)
- Re: Last Mile Design Grant Taylor via NANOG (Feb 09)
- Re: Last Mile Design Miles Fidelman (Feb 09)
- Re: Last Mile Design Mark Tinka (Feb 09)
- RE: Last Mile Design Tony Wicks (Feb 09)
