Firewall Wizards mailing list archives
RE: tunnel vs open a hole
From: "Carroll, Shawn" <SCarroll () chittenden com>
Date: Thu, 10 Apr 2003 15:20:47 -0400
It seems that the real power holder in the whole debate is perhaps that identity having been pointed to and referenced more frequently in recent rants on coding styles and such; the consumer. On that bent, perhaps a holding of breath for change to take place in forcing companies and their coders and such to pay more attention to the details of secureity and bounds checks and all, might well result in a number of purple heads/faces blowing up under-pressure. Afterall, we as a buying public still payout large sums of cash yearly for SUV's that almost need a direct link to a gas pump, roll over wiht slight twists of the steering mechanics to avoind obsticles, and do extremely poorly in crash tests. Even with seatbelts and airbags installed, under federal regulations.
Power, perhaps. But only power in numbers. Of course if people stop buying crap (after first recognizing it as such), then crap will go away and the non-crap will flourish. But I wonder about the mechanisms for this to happen. The buying public at large, I believe, as they make their buying decissions, does NOT believe they have the power to lobby for better things, like better TV programming or better operating systems. I don't know that they FEEL the power of their moral decision not to buy certain TV channels, and that their decision to not buy will, IN AGGREGATE with other like-minded consumers' similar decisions, will either force the quality of programming up, or create a hot untapped market segment for someone to slip into and fill the void. Actually, in the case of TV programming, channels are usually sold in large bundles anyway so you'd be forced to pay for 9/10ths crap for the 1/10th you want. But aside from exercising moral conviction, it takes a bit of faith that (a) the system will work and you won't simply be swinging in the breeze, alone with your moral convictions (b) that others not only would be willing to put their foot down and not buy crap, but do in fact recognize it as crap to begin with. If 90 percent of consumers love Baywatch and the Olsen twins, what are you going to do? I mean, less than 50 percent of Americans vote. A subset of this same public will be buying software. What are they likely to do when their jobs are at risk? Answer: follow the crowd. Those who rise above this are: 1. technically competent, 2. confident, 3. perhaps have trust and buy-in, and 4. few and far between, arguably. A better answer would be, "Don't be one of the ones who doesn't vote, and do the right thing." If no-nonsense measures have to be taken so that SHARED resources are still usable (internet bandwidth) despite the large percentage that aren't as responsible, then so be it. Shawn
Thanks, Ron DuFresne On Wed, 9 Apr 2003, George Capehart wrote:On Tuesday 08 April 2003 11:21 pm, Marcus J. Ranum wrote:Behm, Jeffrey L. wrote:<pet peeve> When will programmers begin (again) to do basic error checking? </pet peeve>It's sure as hell not because the tools don't exist. Evenback in the late1980's you had tools like Saber-C (now CodeCenter) thatdid huge amountsof runtime error checking. The tools are there and havebeen there; it'sthe "get it to market yesterday" mindset and the factthat a lot ofsoftware engineers are spoiled brats that have allowedthe lunatics to takecontrol of the asylum.<pre-rant> Yes, there are *many* tools to help write, trace, and cleancode. There arealso several Web sites, books, and, yes, even codingstandards that deal withwriting sane (and secure) code. There are even wholeprograms designed toimpose good process on the whole system development lifecycle (the RationalUnified Process, the CMMI and SSE-CMM come immediately tomind). And, backin the Dark Ages when I was actually writing code, I *knewbetter* than totake the shortcuts I was taking, but in the face of havingto deliver aproduct yesterday, for free, I was put in the position ofhaving to slam dunka system. </pre-rant> <rant> It's my conviction that all of this is a managementproblem. If the businessowner of the product/project or whatever really gave arat's a**, errorchecking *would* exist in code. Or, even if the projectmanager . . . or thetechnical lead cared, there would be processes in place *atevery phase ofthe SDLC* to identify and manage risk and control errors.We learned(relatively) long ago that the earlier in the SDLC we discover errors/mistakes/problems the cheaper it is to fix.Rhetorical question:When was the last time anyone was on a project where therewas serious focuson identifying problems and fixing them as early aspossible? Gotta say thatI was recently on a very large project ( > 10^7 USD) for avery well-knowncompany and the **_only_** focus was meeting a deliverydate. An importantpoint is that the delivery date had assumed a certain startdate and certainresource level. The start date had slipped by severalmonths and thestaffing level was at less than half of the planned level.So, take a guesshow much code review is going on on that project . . .Guess how much testingwill be done. Guess how much detail *design* was done.Bottom line: Untilbusiness system owners (whether it be of an internalproject or a product)are held accountable for the security, quality andperformance of the systemsfor which they are responsible, programmers will continueto work 16-hourplus days busting their humps and *not* doing any more intheir code thanthey absolutely have to because they don't have ***TIME*** to. </rant> My very cynical $0.02. Sorry . . . I get this way. Seems like the people whowould care the most,care the least. Disclaimer: I work for neither Rational/IBM or the SEI.-- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ admin & senior security consultant: sysinfo.com http://sysinfo.com "Cutting the space budget really restores my faith in humanity. It eliminates dreams, goals, and ideals and lets us get straight to the business of hate, debauchery, and self-annihilation." -- Johnny Hart testing, only testing, and damn good at it too! _______________________________________________ firewall-wizards mailing list firewall-wizards () honor icsalabs com http://honor.icsalabs.com/mailman/listinfo/firewall-wizards
_______________________________________________ firewall-wizards mailing list firewall-wizards () honor icsalabs com http://honor.icsalabs.com/mailman/listinfo/firewall-wizards
Current thread:
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole, (continued)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole George Capehart (Apr 10)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole Duncan Sharp (Apr 10)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole George Capehart (Apr 14)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole Duncan Sharp (Apr 14)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole Duncan Sharp (Apr 16)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole Magosányi Árpád (Apr 11)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole Gary Flynn (Apr 10)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole Paul Robertson (Apr 10)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole Paul Robertson (Apr 10)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole George Capehart (Apr 14)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole George Capehart (Apr 10)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole Marcus J. Ranum (Apr 10)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole Crispin Cowan (Apr 10)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole Gary Flynn (Apr 11)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole Marcus J. Ranum (Apr 11)
- Re: tunnel vs open a hole Steven M. Bellovin (Apr 11)
