nanog mailing list archives
Re: routing table go boom
From: Masataka Ohta <mohta () necom830 hpcl titech ac jp>
Date: Wed, 20 Mar 2013 14:40:11 +0900
Dobbins, Roland wrote:
But if one insists on viewing it through the prism of the end-to-end principle, LISP adheres to it more than does the current routing system.
It merely means you are using a wrong prism. Let's consider a very basic multihoming with two locators, one of which is blackholed. Then, how can an ITR, which initially choose a blackholed locator, know that the locator is not working and fall back to another locator? In general, we should assume protocol used is something unknown to the ITR (not TCP, of course) and/or not assume the ITR is on return path so that the ITR can't have any "knowledge" that an end system receiving any reply. In this case, The function in question can completely and correctly be implemented only with the knowledge and help of the application standing at the endpoints of the communication system. means only the higher stack of the end system have "the knowledge" that sent packets are not replied. But, the end system can't "help" the ITR, because it does not even know the ITR exist. Therefore, Therefore, providing that questioned function as a feature of the communication system itself is not possible. providing that questioned function of destination locator selection for multihoming as a feature of ITR is not possible.
Anyway, I'm done feeding this particular troll for good.
Use a looking glass to see a troll.
Always check the original paper to avoid wrong interpretations
of yours.
Masataka Ohta
PS
Is it time to shutdown LISP WG?
Current thread:
- Re: [c-nsp] DNS amplification, (continued)
- Re: [c-nsp] DNS amplification Christopher Morrow (Mar 19)
- routing table go boom (was: Re: [c-nsp] DNS amplification) Jared Mauch (Mar 19)
- Re: routing table go boom (was: Re: [c-nsp] DNS amplification) Patrick W. Gilmore (Mar 19)
- Re: routing table go boom (was: Re: [c-nsp] DNS amplification) David Conrad (Mar 19)
- Re: routing table go boom Masataka Ohta (Mar 19)
- Re: routing table go boom Dobbins, Roland (Mar 19)
- Re: routing table go boom Masataka Ohta (Mar 19)
- Re: routing table go boom Dobbins, Roland (Mar 19)
- Re: routing table go boom Masataka Ohta (Mar 19)
- Re: routing table go boom Dobbins, Roland (Mar 19)
- Re: routing table go boom Masataka Ohta (Mar 19)
- Re: routing table go boom William Herrin (Mar 19)
- Re: routing table go boom Masataka Ohta (Mar 20)
- Re: routing table go boom Sander Steffann (Mar 20)
- Re: routing table go boom Mike (Mar 20)
- Re: routing table go boom Matthew Walster (Mar 20)
- Re: routing table go boom Jared Mauch (Mar 20)
- Re: routing table go boom Jared Mauch (Mar 20)
- Re: routing table go boom Randy Bush (Mar 21)
- Re: routing table go boom Brielle Bruns (Mar 20)
- Re: routing table go boom Masataka Ohta (Mar 20)
