nanog mailing list archives

Re: routing table go boom


From: Jared Mauch <jared () puck nether net>
Date: Wed, 20 Mar 2013 13:44:25 -0400


On Mar 20, 2013, at 1:30 PM, Mike <mike-nanog () tiedyenetworks com> wrote:



      I appreciate everyones comments on this issue but I think you
nay-sayers are going to lose. I think the future of the internet is
distributed routing where the end points ultimately decide how their
packets flow. I think joe 6-pack should in fact be able to be connected
to as many providers as he wants, should be able to specify any mixture
of connections from consumer dsl to carrier ethernet or beyond, and have
the same level of service as multi-homed bgp speaking networks do today
in terms of route diversity, fail-over and 'portability' (in terms of
bringing your netblocks to another provider). Not a troll, just looking
at the future here.


I certainly think there's a lot that can be done at middle-layers, eg: tunnels
to a few different providers.  I can be on a Comcast CM and ATT DSL link and
establish a link to a tunnel destination in Chicago that is low-latency for me
and the bits will all flow that way.  

The last mile loop problem though?

As of today, neither of those two providers reaches my home with their service.
I doubt I'm going to see a lot of choice unless the market changes considerably.
The last-mile costs are all in the contractors, permits and engineering studies
for weight on the poles.  (Or directional boring/conduit costs underground).

Locally the permit is $200/road crossed, either above or under, this starts
to contribute to the build cost in unexpected ways.  If you looked at the google
fiber proposal, they wanted space on both poles and otherwise to minimize permitting
and other costs.

Last time I talked to someone about outside plant construction the answer was
the cost was functionally strand-agnostic.  That tells me the cost isn't in
the cabling.

- Jared

Current thread: